Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Medieval Cat's avatar

Great terminology! I like games with little crunch but I crave completeness. I guess the ideal game for me is low-crunch, high-completeness, high-believability and high-ruts-escaping (to steal another term for you).

Tim Martin's avatar

I like this definition of completeness, though I wonder about a related concept:

I'm currently struggling with the incompleteness of Shadowdark w/ regard to the thief's backstab ability (what counts as "unaware" of the thief)? But imagine if SD removed that ability, and in fact removed all mention of hiding or sneaking from the rules. Players would still *want* to sneak at times, and the DM would have to provide rulings. Would this count as SD being incomplete? Or in your view, would the official rules be saying "there is no sneaking in SD, just like there is no domain-level play"?

The bigger question is what counts as a situation that the existing rules directly led us to? Did dungeoncrawling "lead" us to sneaking, or did we bring that concept in ourselves (in this example)?

17 more comments...

Ready for more?